Blogs related to Hana Kimi

[buttercupmm]

joemer.blogetery.com/2008/03/24/sti-n-says-hana-kimi-the-original-mas-maganda-kumpara-sa-japaneese/

STi-N Says: Hana Kimi The Original - Mas Maganda Kumpara Sa Japaneese
Posted on March 24th, 2008 in ABS-CBN, GMA by joemer ||


STi-N Says: Hana Kimi The Original - Mas Maganda Kumpara Sa Japaneese
Version!!!

Nang nagdaang “Holy Week” ay pinanood namin ang Hana Kimi The Original
at Hana Kimi Japaneese Version. Labing walo kaming tumapos nang
naturang mga palabas.Ayon sa aming pag obserba, mas nagustuhan namin ang
istorya, nang the original version. Kahit pa hango sa orihinal ang Japaneese
version, ay may mga eksena din namang nabago dito. Mula po sa aming
labing walo na nanood, na tumayo bilang mga panelista, 14 out of 18
panelista, ang bumoto na mas nagustuhan nila ang orihinal mula sa Taiwan,
samantalang 4 out of 18 panelista ang nakagusto sa Japaneese version. Sa
mga tauhan naman, base sa itsura sa bidang babae ay 10 out of 18 ang
nagsabi na mas maganda itsura nang Japaneese version. Samantalang 8 out
of 18 naman ang pumanig mula sa orihinal na version. Base naman sa
pagkakaganap nang bidang babae, ay 12 out of 18 ang nakagusto sa
performance na pinakita nang babae mula sa orihinal na version. Samantalang 6 out
of 18 naman ang nagandahan sa pinakita nang babae mula sa Japaneese
version. Sa mga lalake namang gumanap, base sa itsura nito ay 17 out of
18 ang nakagusto sa itsura mula sa orihinal na version. Samantalang 1
lamang mula sa 18 na panelista ang nakagusto sa version mula Japan. Base
naman sa husay na pinakita sa pagarte nang bidang lalake, ay 15 out of
18 ang nakagusto sa galing na pinakita mula sa orihinal na version.
Samantalang 3 out of 18 lang sa Japaneese Version.
Linilinaw lang po namin, na ito ay base sa ginawa naming butohan sa
aming napanood na tumayo na din mga panelista. Lima na babae na may edad
13, 16, 22, 30 at 42. Samantalang Walong lalake na may mga edad na 14,
18, 25, 27, 32,36, 37, at 48. At lima namang mga kabilang sa third sex
na may edad na 16, 19, 24, 32, at 33 ang mga nagsilbing panelista.

Mangyari po lamang na magiwan po kayo nang inyong kumento, tungkol sa usaping ito. Dahil dito po sa SHOWBIZZ TOP i-NEWS, laging pananaw nyo lang po ang siyang laging mahalaga at importante para sa amin. for your comments, suggestion or complains (regarding the site) you can e-mail us at STi_N23 at yahoo.com Maraming Maraming Salamat Po Sa Walang Sawa Nyong Pag Supporta Sa Amin!!!

[buttercupmm]

gollydays.wordpress.com/2008/03/26/why-im-for-hana-kimi-japan/

Why I’m for Hana Kimi Japan
Posted by icecola under Hana Kimi, Japan, PinoyTV, Taiwan



First off, I don’t care about the local TV networks war. I gave up on TV years ago after I started MTV and Arirang. I never gave a d**n on this season’s PBB. I’m so not into TV, I’m beginning to doubt myself if I am a Filipino. Ok, that may be an exaggeration, but I really feel like throwing up every time I’m reminded of those lame network wars.

Now, I think I may be bias for loving the Japan version and being very open about it. But in fairness, I gave myself a chance to watch Hana Kimi Taiwan. But really, if I were to compare it with the Japanese version (which I watched first, and may be a factor why I can’t love the TW version), the story is more draggy on the TW version. I should rant more but I prefer to make a list instead.

HK-JP has more cute guys. I don’t really think it should matter but it matters to me. There’s no cute guy in HK-TW. Wu Chun? Hello? He can’t even speak straight Chinese. And if you can, watch the NGs, he’s such a sloppy actor.
Horikita Maki must be a girl too cute to be a boy but Ella, come on, Ella, the only thing that maybe would convince me that she’s a girl in a boy’s role is the way she speaks, but the rest, she’s too over-acting and annoying, I’m convinced she’s a girl. Who looks like a boy.
Where have all the funny contests gone? Sure, the manga must not have those antics but come on, just read the manga if you want the story just like it.
The dorm people, where are the dorm people in the TW version? Those dorm heads may be annoying, but they’re annoyingly funny.
Nakatsu and his monologues is enough to kill boredom after you watch the whole I-don’t-care-how-many-episodes-of-TW-version-since-I-can’t-get-past-episode-4. That’s the product of a good stage play actor who started the business since he’s 12. Those Fahrenheit guys, what do they do? Can they sing? Well I don’t want to try hearing them.
EDIT/UPDATE: I forgot to mention about the songs. The opening and closing songs. They may be the only song I could remember about the drama (together with Ikemen Boogie), but they are enough to brighten up my day. Peach by Otsuka Ai (I’m still trying to learn how to sing that song properly for Karaoke purposes), and Ikenai Taiyou by Orange Range (which burst hormones). I made a previous post about this. How could I like those sweet sounding HK-TW soundtrack (sung by members of certain pop groups who also happen to be the main cast of their drama) when I can be my girly girl and jump on my bed while singing the JP songs (which probably isn’t possible still since I live on a double deck.)
Wah. I can’t think anymore. If you think these reasons are too few, I don’t blame you. If you like the Taiwan version better, I don’t blame you. These are all I could remember right now. But these will always be enough for me.

If anybody got offended, I’m sorry. But these are all things I really want to say. Who knows, I might like Ella someday when I get really bored and ran out of things to watch. But right now, if there’s anyone asking "what the hell, which version should I watch? which is funnier?" — here’s definitely my answer: THE JAPANESE VERSION. But again all of this is just me.

Here, this must be my last chance to compare which "has more fun". It’s up to you and your taste.

[KAT♥]

wah?!
sabay pa kming nanood ng hana kimi taiwan..holy week..haha..

hhmmm base sa aking nabasa..
masyado clang nadadala..
matindi ang kanilang mga kumento..
hindi na ako makapagsalita ukol sa kanilang mga opinyon...

[Richel]

Honestly, I couldn't blame some of the people who dislikes Ella's performance, or her looks for that matter, The first time I saw her I was really intrigue and I just got hook by how well they portray each character, Ella's looks grew in me while watching HK. At first I was just watching it because it's so funny and I easily get attracted by Chun, Well, each person have there own preference, Just to defend Ella's acting and looks, Her acting is comical that fits with the story and her looks? Well, the part says she really needs to look like a guy right? So, she very well got that covered but when she dress up, she's really really pretty! Just my two cents guys!

[*~mrs~moya05~chen~*]

omg.. i hate icecola.. how dare she talk bout wu chun like that!? at least wu chun know how to speak mandarin rather than her.. and al least wu chun is trying his best.. >.< i really hate her.. she's so.. ugh! >.<

[lourdescoolchun]

for me i admit i when i first saw the pictures of this drama it was kinda weird because of ella appearance thinking how a guy like wu chun would fall in love in a girl who looks exactly like a guy. But it all changes when i first saw the trailer it made me realize how this drama is so nice and romantic funny drama, and eventhough before i know who are the fahrenheit members are and what kind of boy band they are i should admit that this is only the time that i have really notice them and got hooked with them just like f4 before most especially with wu chun...i really like the chemistry of ella and chun on screen hope to see more of them..

GO ELLACHUN!!!

[CutieHeart918*maine*]

kahit ako matapos kong panuorin jap and taiwan ver...
mas nakakainlove at nakakaenjoy panuorin ang taiwan ver...

at infairness bagay talaga kay ella ang role niya!
ung babae kasi dun sa jap ver... masyado siyang maganda para hindi mo mahalatang babae siya(hindi ko sinasabi na pangit si ella, i love ella because of xtine)

[CutieHeart918*maine*]

hahah grabe naman ung opinion nung sa seond post ni buttercupmm
kung sino man siya, super bulag naman niya!
si nakatsu lang ata ang may itsura sa jap ver
tapos sasabihin niya na "it matters to her daw" hehe*peace*
yah maybe hindi nga nung una magaling si chun sa mandarin
pero reasonable naman kasi hindi naman siya lumaki sa taiwan or kung san man!

kung ako nga na pure chinese din na nandito sa pinas pinanganak e minsan nakakalimutan din ang magmandarin hahhaha
*ikompare ba naman ang sarili kay chun??*